• Law
College

Thank you for visiting Malia went to the chiropractor after a slip and fall accident In the examination room she noticed an autographed 1993 Derek Jeter rookie baseball card. This page is designed to guide you through key points and clear explanations related to the topic at hand. We aim to make your learning experience smooth, insightful, and informative. Dive in and discover the answers you're looking for!

Malia went to the chiropractor after a slip and fall accident. In the examination room, she noticed an autographed 1993 Derek Jeter rookie baseball card. Malia picked it up and gave it to her chiropractor (who owns the building), telling him to give the card to the owner if he or she should return for it. After a few months, Malia returned to the chiropractor's office with her personal injury attorney. When she discovered that no one had returned to claim the baseball card, Malia demanded that the chiropractor give it to her. He refused, and Malia's attorney filed a lawsuit the next day.

In whose favor should a court rule?

A. Malia
B. Chiropractor
C. Previous owner
D. Personal injury attorney

Answer :

Final answer:

The court would likely rule in favor of the chiropractor because he is in rightful possession of the lost property at his business, and Malia has no legal claim to it. Correct answer is b) Chiropractor.

Explanation:

In this scenario, a court would likely rule in favor of b) the Chiropractor, as he is in rightful possession of the property found within the premises of his business. When Malia handed the Derek Jeter rookie baseball card to the chiropractor, she was entrusting it to him as a bailee for the true owner under the assumption that the owner might return for it. Since Malia neither found the card on her property nor has legal claim to it, she does not have superior rights to the card over the chiropractor.

The true owner, if identifiable, would be the rightful claimant of the card. The personal injury attorney's involvement is irrelevant to the ownership of the card. Therefore, the court should rule in favor of the party who has had the physical possession and where the item was found unless the original owner reclaims it.

Thank you for reading the article Malia went to the chiropractor after a slip and fall accident In the examination room she noticed an autographed 1993 Derek Jeter rookie baseball card. We hope the information provided is useful and helps you understand this topic better. Feel free to explore more helpful content on our website!

Rewritten by : Jeany