Thank you for visiting Ross held that prima facie duties are tentatively binding so when they conflict we must rely on intuition to choose the stronger duty A True. This page is designed to guide you through key points and clear explanations related to the topic at hand. We aim to make your learning experience smooth, insightful, and informative. Dive in and discover the answers you're looking for!
Answer :
Final answer:
The statement that Ross believed prima facie duties are tentatively binding and require us to use judgment when they conflict is true. Ross argued that in situations with conflicting duties, we determine our most pressing, actual duty through a judgement that balances prima facie rightness and wrongness.
Explanation:
The statement that Ross held that prima facie duties are tentatively binding and when they conflict, we must rely on intuition to choose the stronger duty, is True. Sir William David Ross believed that our moral obligations are prima facie duties, which he defined as self-evident duties recognized through experience and maturity. These duties are not absolute but tentatively binding, meaning they hold until proven otherwise by a stronger, competing duty in a particular situation.
Ross identified several prima facie duties such as duties of fidelity, reparation, gratitude, promoting the maximum aggregate of good, and non-maleficence. He asserted that, in situations where multiple conflicting prima facie duties are relevant, we must use judgment to determine which duty is most pressing and thus, our actual duty. This process involves considering the facts and potential consequences of the action to decide on the greatest balance of prima facie rightness over prima facie wrongness.
Competing Duties
In real-world scenarios involving moral dilemmas, such as choosing whether to break a promise to help someone in need, Ross argued that our obligation to act on the more pressing duty overrides the less critical ones, thereby fulfilling our actual duty. He also believed that when such a decision is made, there should be a recognition of the prima facie wrongness of not fulfilling the lesser duty, if any exists.
Thank you for reading the article Ross held that prima facie duties are tentatively binding so when they conflict we must rely on intuition to choose the stronger duty A True. We hope the information provided is useful and helps you understand this topic better. Feel free to explore more helpful content on our website!
- You are operating a recreational vessel less than 39 4 feet long on federally controlled waters Which of the following is a legal sound device
- Which step should a food worker complete to prevent cross contact when preparing and serving an allergen free meal A Clean and sanitize all surfaces
- For one month Siera calculated her hometown s average high temperature in degrees Fahrenheit She wants to convert that temperature from degrees Fahrenheit to degrees
Rewritten by : Jeany
